AT HOME IN TACOMA
A blog about all the little things that make Tacoma home.

Updated Craftsman with Vintage Charm in Downtown Puyallup

Kelli+Jo Hjalseth • November 12, 2025

Brimming with historic character yet updated with modern conveniences, this classic Craftsman in Downtown Puyallup checks all of the boxes! Featuring a 2,640-square-foot layout, this home includes 4 bedrooms and 2 baths alongside generous living spaces, a beautifully updated kitchen, and so much more. And don’t miss the spacious backyard and detached garage that provide even more fun and flexibility. Located at 409 5th Avenue NE Puyallup, WA 98372 and less than 1 mile to schools, freeway access, the Puyallup Station (where you can catch the Sounder Train!), grocery shopping, dining and more, this classic Craftsman in Downtown Puyallup is listed for $575,000. 

Boasting several updates, this home offers the best of both worlds. Built in 1918, several original details and vintage elements transport you back in time in the best way. Crisp trimwork, gorgeous doors, and stunning wood elements are just a few of the details sure to delight, and updates have been carefully chosen to complement the historic design. Meanwhile, discover upgraded electric, plumbing, vinyl windows, A/C, and several other updates to the kitchen, all promising the comforts of modern living. 

A large covered front porch is ready to greet you each time you arrive home, and this inviting outdoor retreat is a lovely spot to take in the fresh air and catch up with visitors. From here, the front door opens up into the foyer where you’re immediately greeted by this home’s impeccably curated and maintained character. 

Relax in the warm and welcoming living room and enjoy quality time with loved ones gathered in the dining room. Laidback evenings basking in the comfort of home are just as fulfilling as entertaining guests for holiday get-togethers and other celebrations. From here, rich engineered hardwood floors flow into the kitchen, a well-appointed space that’s been expertly designed. The updated kitchen features stainless steel appliances and granite counters alongside ample cabinetry storage. It’s truly a picture-perfect scene! 

The main level also includes a bedroom and a full bath, and upstairs you’ll find 3 bedrooms and a full bath, all with original flooring, built-ins, and walk-in closets. This home even has a dedicated laundry space, and a small finished room in the large unfinished basement is ready to become your home office or hobby room. In addition to all of the versatility that awaits in the unfinished basement, the detached garage with carriage doors also awaits your vision. Plus, an extra-long driveway leads to the garage—you’ll never run out of parking! 

One of this property’s other perks is the fact that it has a spacious fully fenced backyard with a dog run. Enjoy this outdoor getaway as is and let your pups play with peace of mind, or put your imagination to work and design landscaping and build raised garden beds in the years to come. 

What Is It Like to Live in Downtown Puyallup, Washington? 


At 409 5th Avenue NE Puyallup, WA 98372, you’re surrounded by amenities and attractions and less than 1 mile from shopping and dining to schools and commuting options. Schools and parks are merely blocks away, as are several eateries (popular picks like Crockett’s Public House and Powerhouse Restaurant & Brewery are right at your fingertips). This particular location is especially great for commuters—both Highway 512 and Highway 167 are just a few minutes from home, and the Puyallup Station is 0.6 miles away. Here you can hop on the Sounder Train or a bus to Seattle or Tacoma, and many stops in between and beyond. The Washington State Fairgrounds and MultiCare Good Samaritan Hospital are also no more than 5 minutes away. 


Would you like to
learn more about this classic Craftsman for sale in Downtown Puyallup? Contact Sharon Benson here and Kelli Jo Hjalseth here!


Absolutely brimming with thoughtful updates, this home nestled in Tacoma’s established Brooktree nei
By Kelli+Jo Hjalseth November 12, 2025
Absolutely brimming with thoughtful updates, this home nestled in Tacoma’s established Brooktree neighborhood is move-in ready! Updates ensure you can move right in with peace of mind, and beautifully curated spaces are sure to delight. The 1,759-square-foot layout includes 3 bedrooms and 2.5 baths (including a dreamy
By Kelli+Jo Hjalseth October 7, 2025
Lovingly maintained and renovated to perfection, this turnkey North Tacoma home is a total masterpiece. From updated systems that promise modern convenience to captivating vintage details that show off this home’s original character, here you’ll find 2,371 square feet of curated beauty. All systems have been updated, i
By Sharon Benson September 19, 2025
Perfectly situated right on the shores of Wollochet Bay in Gig Harbor, this 0.97-acre property with 128 feet of waterfront is ready for you to bring your ideas and build your dream home! Surrounded by scenic farmland, Pacific Northwest greenery, and picturesque residential communities, this property offers the once-in-